The pros and cons of renting in the Netherlands: an honest look at the housing market

The Netherlands is known worldwide for its unique approach to living. Whether you're an expat settling here or a local starter, choosing between renting and buying is one of the most important financial decisions you'll make. Unlike many other countries, the Netherlands has a highly regulated rental market, with a strong emphasis on tenant protection.

However, the huge tightness in the current market casts a shadow over the system. While renting offers unprecedented flexibility and protection, it also comes with high costs and uncertainty due to fierce competition. To make an informed choice, it is essential to understand both the bright side and the dark side of the Dutch rental system.

The benefits of renting in the Netherlands

Renting is often seen as “throwing money away”, but in the Dutch system, there are significant benefits that you simply don't have as a homeowner.

Flexibility and mobility

The biggest advantage of renting is freedom. In the Netherlands, most rental contracts can be canceled monthly after the first fixed period (often one year). This is ideal for people who need to move for their careers, starters who don't know where to root yet, or people whose household composition may change. You're not tied to a thirty-year mortgage and you don't have to worry about selling a home in a declining market.

Comprehensive tenant protection

The Netherlands has one of the strongest legal frameworks for tenant protection in the world. A landlord can't just kick you out. Even when the contract expires, there are strict rules for eviction. In addition, the rent commission protects tenants against unreasonable rents and poor maintenance. If the quality of your home does not meet the legal requirements, you can often enforce a rent reduction.

No worries about major maintenance

As a tenant, you have a financially predictable life when it comes to your home. Will the boiler break down? Is the roof leaking? Does the outside need to be painted? These are the landlord's concerns (and costs). You don't have to keep thousands of dollars on hand for unexpected repairs to the building's structure.

Financial support via housing allowance

For people with a lower income, the Dutch government offers housing allowance. This is a monthly contribution to the rental costs, so that living in the social sector or sometimes even in the free sector remains affordable. This social safety net ensures that living is treated as a basic right.

The disadvantages of renting in the Netherlands

Despite the good protection, the reality on the street is often more unruly. The disadvantages of renting have increased significantly in recent years due to the housing crisis.

Extreme scarcity and competition

The biggest disadvantage is simply finding a home. In popular cities such as Amsterdam, Utrecht and Eindhoven, demand far exceeds supply. This leads to “home draws” with thousands of candidates or “hospital nights” where the chance of getting a room is minimal. The stress associated with finding a place can have a huge impact on your well-being.

High rents in the free sector

Although the social rental sector is regulated, prices in the free sector (for incomes that fall above the social threshold) have skyrocketed. Tenants in the Randstad often pay 40% to 50% of their net income in rent. In contrast to a mortgage, where the costs often remain stable or fall as you repay, the rent rises every year due to the inflation adjustment.

No wealth accrual

This is the classic argument against renting. You will permanently lose every euro you pay in rent. You don't build up equity in the form of excess value on a house. In the long term, this can make a big difference in your pension accrual or overall financial stability. While homeowners benefit from increases in property values, tenants are only looking at rising costs.

Limited freedom in the home

Do you want to break a wall, completely renew the kitchen or install solar panels? As a tenant, you always need permission from the landlord. In many cases, you are not allowed to radically change the home, so that the house never feels 100% “yours”. You live in someone else's taste, and when you leave, you often have to restore the home to its original state.

The changing legislation: Fixed Lease Contracts Act

It is important to mention that the Netherlands is currently in a transition phase. Since July 2024, the Permanent Lease Contracts Act has been in force, which restricts the offer of temporary contracts (for example two years).

• The advantage: Tenants get more security and do not have to move every two years.
• The disadvantage: Critics fear that private landlords would now rather sell their homes than rent them out, because they “will never get rid of the tenant”. This could further reduce the supply of rental properties in the short term.

Rent or buy?

Choosing to rent in the Netherlands is often a choice for security and convenience versus the financial growth of buying.

Renting is the best option if you:

• Expected to stay in the same place for less than five years.
• You don't want to worry about maintenance and taxes.
• You can make use of social rent or housing allowance.
• You need the flexibility to switch quickly in your life.

Renting is not a good option if you:

• You have a stable high income and want to build up wealth.
• Want to completely renovate the house to your own taste.
• Want to have maximum control over your long-term monthly payments.

In the current market, unfortunately, the choice is not always up to the tenant; availability often determines what your options are. Nevertheless, thanks to the strong legal basis, renting in the Netherlands remains a high-quality way of living that can offer a lot of peace of mind in a turbulent world.

‍